Disk Detective Talk
Galaxy judging by SED
#goodcandidate ?
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate IMO
#noAO #goodcandidate
What type of star it is?
goodcandidate
Not a star according to SED?
agree
A QSO?
extended in WISE
IRAS 09381-5220 -- Star
Interesting SED , what it is?
Maybe #goodcandidate
Sadly extended in WISE
Kind of disagree, #goodcandidate imo
multiple
good candidate?
Looks like it from SED
agree goodcandidate
good candidate
Likely QSO
IMHO good candidate; #goodcandidate
agree good
sadly looks contaminated in WISE
Good candidate, in my opinion #goodcandidate
Really? it looks so bright
maybe multiple
IMO goodcandidate
Crowded region, BUT no star in circle, #goodcandidate?
Galaxy most likely
Contaminated in WISE, sadly
Contaminated in WISE , sadly
contaminated in WISE
Good candidate, #goodcandidate
same question
Good candidate , #goodcandidate
Extended in WISE
Good candidate in my opinion, #goodcandidate
extended in wise unfortunately
no simbad, but looks like QSO according to SED
sadly, contaminated in WISE
#goodcandidate?
BD+02 3621 -- Star
DSS2 Blue useless, otherwise goodcandidate
maybe
looks like
goodcandidate?
Star?
yep extended
maybe #goodcandidate
though ~10" to the N there is a second source in 2MASS
AllWISE J085415.27-472930.9
W1-W4 = 0.735 not good candidate
CD-47 4490 -- Star
good or blend?
multiple or good?
Could be good candidate
AllWISE J042243.71+172919.6
W1-W4 = 1.345
Maybe #multiple or goodcandidate?
IMO #goodcandidate
Maybe multiple or good candidate?
Multiple?
#goodcandidate #noSimbad
Good candidate
extended? or good?
no sdss in disk detective
DSS looks good, very red star in SDSS
yep
I think still #goodcandidate
QSO?
Yep
what they said
maybe good
maybe not good
borderline case, maybe multiple
agree #goodcandidate
#noSIMBAD
SDSS images are messed up ; doesn't look bad in DSS images
dunno maybe #goodcandidate
hmm multiple?
sadly contaminated in WISE
agree, good candidate
Good?
HD 214767 -- Star
V* V728 Oph -- Variable Star of Mira Cet type
Huh? what is wrong with SDSS images?
Otherwise looks like good candidate
Contaminated in WISE
multiple stars in circle
Looks good, although faint
V* V2017 Sgr -- Asymptotic Giant Branch Star (He-burning)
busy region, but none in red circle
maybe good candidate
multiple objects
blend
AKARI-IRC-V1 J0658543-311026 -- Star
Good candidate IMO
Maybe good candidate?
Looks extended in WISE
UCAC2 1032835 -- Star
Good candidate? or not?
maybe good?
Yeah, same question
Agree
A bit of moving, but is a good candidate?
I thought it was good
There are visible objects nearby otherwise could be good candidate
some objects within the circle
I think could be good candidate, despite a bit of jumping in 2MASS
yep, suck that it is extended in WISE
could be good candidate, WISE is not very good
Maybe some objects within red circle but seems rather good
Good candidate?
Agree good
I think, #goodcandidate
could be contaminated
Yes, I agree
Agree, V 7.37
HD 114800
Yes, I agree good candidate
Multiple objects, thought sed looks good
maybe galaxy or qso
good
Contominated in WISE
C* 661 -- Carbon Star
AKARI-IRC-V1 J1843583-453106
Too bad it is contaminated
SED looks good, star nearby, shifting?
IMO good candidate
Agree, #goodcandidate
TYC 9445-2135-1 -- Star
I would call good despite presence of companion
seems ok
Dunno, seems to have companion
To say the least (
Ok more or less
possible contamination
V* V495 Lyr -- Semi-regular pulsating Star
Seems ok
Possible contamination
I would go for good
Yes, good one
RAVE J115355.1-512041 -- Star
Multiple objects
NSVS 1588852 -- Variable Star
Seems ok more or less
EM* GGR 84 -- Emission-line Star
Companion nearby, but seems to be ok
Looks ok
Seems to be Ok
I do understand you
Seems more or less ok
Not exactly round in DSS?
Ok, thanks for explanation
How critical presence of the companion? If we have bright star and fainter companion?
Probably contaminated by companion?
Good? seems to be slightly shifting in WISE?
Worth a follow-up?
HD 165277
IRAS 22460+5505 -- Star
SED looks good, object nearby
Can be called good?
Thanks
Otherwise good?
Good? thought multiple objects in circle plus slight jumping
good?
IRAS 20540+3109 -- Star
seems good
TYC 3162-1260-1 -- Star
2MASS J19494489+3430110 -- Variable Star
Second object nearby, good SED
TYC 8958-27-1 -- Star
TYC 2128-2121-1
second star nearby, but otherwise #goodcandidate?
Hmm #goodcandidate?
Another star within red circle, SED look reasonably good
Good
Agree, good
Good candidate? SED say so?
SED looks good?
Except there is multiple objects in the circle
Otherwise good candidate
#goodcandidate, though according to simbad it is a galaxy?
Object nearby, maybe still #goodcandidate?
Hmm good SED?? Not a good candidate by formal criteria, but maybe?
Why it such a bright source in 22 micron WISE? Dust?
#goodcandidate !
Hmm ,, unusual SED, high IR
And a #goodcandidate, I think , judging by SED
Is it a good candidate?
#galaxy and nebula nearby?
Nebula, nearby?
There is a strange blue object nearby ~23 59 01.83 -47 21 48.6 Visible only in DSS and DSS 2 ( Blue ) .. artifact?
The source of this bright circle in WISE appears to be Mrk 507 -- Seyfert 1 Galaxy 17 48 38.423 +68 42 16.06
Galaxy judging by SED
#goodcandidate ?
#goodcandidate ?
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate IMO
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
#noAO #goodcandidate
What type of star it is?
#goodcandidate
goodcandidate
Not a star according to SED?
#goodcandidate
agree
A QSO?
extended in WISE
IRAS 09381-5220 -- Star
Interesting SED , what it is?
Maybe #goodcandidate
Sadly extended in WISE
#goodcandidate
Kind of disagree, #goodcandidate imo
multiple
good candidate?
Looks like it from SED
#goodcandidate
agree goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
good candidate
Likely QSO
IMHO good candidate; #goodcandidate
agree good
sadly looks contaminated in WISE
Good candidate, in my opinion #goodcandidate
Really? it looks so bright
maybe multiple
goodcandidate
agree
IMO goodcandidate
Crowded region, BUT no star in circle, #goodcandidate?
agree
Galaxy most likely
agree
Contaminated in WISE, sadly
Contaminated in WISE , sadly
multiple
contaminated in WISE
Good candidate, #goodcandidate
same question
Good candidate , #goodcandidate
Extended in WISE
Good candidate in my opinion, #goodcandidate
extended in wise unfortunately
no simbad, but looks like QSO according to SED
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
sadly, contaminated in WISE
#goodcandidate?
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
BD+02 3621 -- Star
#goodcandidate
DSS2 Blue useless, otherwise goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate IMO
maybe
#goodcandidate
looks like
goodcandidate?
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
Star?
#goodcandidate
yep extended
multiple
agree
maybe #goodcandidate
though ~10" to the N there is a second source in 2MASS
AllWISE J085415.27-472930.9
W1-W4 = 0.735 not good candidate
CD-47 4490 -- Star
good or blend?
multiple or good?
Could be good candidate
AllWISE J042243.71+172919.6
W1-W4 = 1.345
Maybe #multiple or goodcandidate?
IMO #goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
Maybe multiple or good candidate?
#goodcandidate?
good candidate?
#goodcandidate?
#goodcandidate
Multiple?
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
maybe multiple
#goodcandidate #noSimbad
Good candidate
extended? or good?
no sdss in disk detective
DSS looks good, very red star in SDSS
#goodcandidate ?
yep
I think still #goodcandidate
QSO?
#goodcandidate #noSimbad
Yep
multiple
#goodcandidate
what they said
maybe good
Maybe #goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
maybe not good
multiple
borderline case, maybe multiple
maybe good
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
agree #goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
#noSIMBAD
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
SDSS images are messed up ; doesn't look bad in DSS images
dunno maybe #goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
hmm multiple?
#goodcandidate
sadly contaminated in WISE
agree, good candidate
Good?
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
HD 214767 -- Star
Yep
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
V* V728 Oph -- Variable Star of Mira Cet type
Huh? what is wrong with SDSS images?
Otherwise looks like good candidate
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
Contaminated in WISE
multiple stars in circle
Looks good, although faint
V* V2017 Sgr -- Asymptotic Giant Branch Star (He-burning)
busy region, but none in red circle
maybe good candidate
multiple objects
blend
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate
AKARI-IRC-V1 J0658543-311026 -- Star
maybe good
#goodcandidate IMO
yep
Good candidate IMO
Good?
Maybe good candidate?
Looks extended in WISE
UCAC2 1032835 -- Star
Good?
Good candidate? or not?
Contaminated in WISE
multiple objects
maybe good?
Yeah, same question
Contaminated in WISE
Agree
A bit of moving, but is a good candidate?
I thought it was good
agree
good candidate?
#goodcandidate?
Contaminated in WISE
IMO #goodcandidate
There are visible objects nearby otherwise could be good candidate
some objects within the circle
agree
I think could be good candidate, despite a bit of jumping in 2MASS
yep, suck that it is extended in WISE
could be good candidate, WISE is not very good
Good candidate
Maybe some objects within red circle but seems rather good
Good candidate?
Agree good
I think, #goodcandidate
could be contaminated
Yes, I agree
Agree, V 7.37
HD 114800
Yes, I agree good candidate
maybe good
Multiple objects, thought sed looks good
maybe galaxy or qso
good
Extended in WISE
#goodcandidate
Contominated in WISE
C* 661 -- Carbon Star
AKARI-IRC-V1 J1843583-453106
Too bad it is contaminated
SED looks good, star nearby, shifting?
Good?
IMO good candidate
Agree, #goodcandidate
TYC 9445-2135-1 -- Star
I would call good despite presence of companion
agree
seems ok
Dunno, seems to have companion
To say the least (
Ok more or less
possible contamination
V* V495 Lyr -- Semi-regular pulsating Star
Seems ok
Possible contamination
I would go for good
Yes, good one
agree
Seems ok
RAVE J115355.1-512041 -- Star
Multiple objects
Agree
NSVS 1588852 -- Variable Star
Seems ok more or less
EM* GGR 84 -- Emission-line Star
Companion nearby, but seems to be ok
Looks ok
Seems to be Ok
I do understand you
Seems more or less ok
Not exactly round in DSS?
Ok, thanks for explanation
How critical presence of the companion? If we have bright star and fainter companion?
Probably contaminated by companion?
Good? seems to be slightly shifting in WISE?
Worth a follow-up?
HD 165277
IRAS 22460+5505 -- Star
SED looks good, object nearby
Can be called good?
Thanks
Otherwise good?
Good? thought multiple objects in circle plus slight jumping
Good?
good?
IRAS 20540+3109 -- Star
seems good
TYC 3162-1260-1 -- Star
Good?
2MASS J19494489+3430110 -- Variable Star
Good?
Good?
Second object nearby, good SED
Good candidate?
TYC 8958-27-1 -- Star
TYC 2128-2121-1
Agree
good
second star nearby, but otherwise #goodcandidate?
Hmm #goodcandidate?
Good?
Another star within red circle, SED look reasonably good
Good
good candidate
Agree, good
Good candidate
Good candidate? SED say so?
SED looks good?
Except there is multiple objects in the circle
Otherwise good candidate
Good?
#goodcandidate, though according to simbad it is a galaxy?
Object nearby, maybe still #goodcandidate?
Hmm good SED?? Not a good candidate by formal criteria, but maybe?
Good?
Why it such a bright source in 22 micron WISE? Dust?
#goodcandidate
#goodcandidate !
Hmm ,, unusual SED, high IR
And a #goodcandidate, I think , judging by SED
Is it a good candidate?
#galaxy and nebula nearby?
Nebula, nearby?
There is a strange blue object nearby ~23 59 01.83 -47 21 48.6
Visible only in DSS and DSS 2 ( Blue ) .. artifact?
The source of this bright circle in WISE appears to be Mrk 507 -- Seyfert 1 Galaxy
17 48 38.423 +68 42 16.06